The Online Portfolio Of A.J. Dugger III
  • Home
  • Cover Stories
  • Gallery Of Work
  • Books
  • Celebrity Interviews
  • Awards
  • Blog
  • Contact Info
  • Resume
  • Quotes
  • Web Designs
  • Voice-Over Work
  • Forum

Shattered Glass and All The President's Men

5/29/2011

0 Comments

 
Picture
The first time I saw Shattered Glass was in my journalism class at APSU in 2005. To be honest, I didn't pay much attention to the first half of the film. There was a hottie sitting next to me that I used to flirt with regularly. Haha! That's what happens when you're a single, 19 year-old on a college campus. But the second half of the movie caught my attention, even more so than the curvy woman that sat next to me. The reason? The journalist in the movie, Stephen Glass, was caught making up his articles.

The film is based on the true story of Stephen Glass, who wrote regularly for the New Republic Magazine, while freelancing for Harpers, George, and other publications. It was the first movie I'd seen that captured the real essence of the job I enjoy. It also showcased the pressures that writers can easily find themselves under. As a matter of fact, there was one scene where a female writer at the magazine was jealous of Stephen's popularity. Glass appeared to be the real deal; editors from other publications kept contacting him, he wrote front page articles, and was bringing in a lot of money. He had the career that every hotshot journalist dreams of. But of course, no one knew his secret yet.

Glass was gradually exposed after a reporter from Forbes (Adam Penenburg) tried to write a follow-up article on a story Glass had previously written, only to discover that the entire story was made up. Things began to unravel from there. But one thing I love about the film is that Glass' downfall was a gradual process; it's almost like watching the sand dwindle in an hourglass. Rather than confessing and resigning, Glass fought back. He created fake websites, business cards, voicemails, emails, and other things to cover his tracks and fool his editors. With every piece of 'evidence' Glass created, he only dug his hole deeper. The 25 year-old writer was finally fired when his editor, Chuck Lane, discovered that Glass' brother was posing as one of his sources.

Why did Stephen Glass do this? No one knows for sure. But there are pressures in journalism, and this movie revealed some of them. Glass was certainly under stress--writing for so many publications and even attending law school at night. Was he a good writer deep down? I have my doubts. I've read that his stories generally were not good narratives until his editors tinkered with them. I heard a lot of people say that Stephen would make an excellent novelist or screenwriter. After all, his stories sounded like hollywood cinemas. But again, this is largely because of his editors and colleagues who would help him. I have Stephen's novel, The Fabulist, and though it's not a horrible read, it can't compare with Glass's creative fiction during his journalism career. But, his book is intriguing all the same because he walks you through how he fooled the fact-checkers and editors.

Another thing that struck me about the movie was the portrayal of Stephen's editors. His first editor, the late Michael Kelly, was laid back, fun and supportive. The entire staff loved him. His successor, Chuck Lane, didn't have Kelly's sense of humor. In fact, one of the writers in the movie described him as "humorless." Editors are different everywhere you work. I've had some that I really enjoyed working for, and others I'd prefer not to work with again. It's the luck of the draw. It's like picking out a pet kitten. You have no idea what kind of personality it will have until you interact with it.

Ultimately, I think Glass only got away with his crimes because The New Republic didn't allow photos in their magazine. Also, with TNR being an opinionated magazine, Glass could write the things he knew his readers wanted to hear. Writing straight-forward AP-style articles like the ones in U.S. newspapers would have made cheating more difficult for Glass. Shattered Glass is my favorite journalism movie without doubt.

I screened All The President's Men sometime late last year. The movie is about the reporters who uncovered the Watergate Scandal. Like Shattered Glass, the film gives an in-depth look into the world of journalism. You see reporters crouched behind desks, talking to sources on the phone or writing articles. You also see that journalists will sometimes run into sources that don't want to be revealed, like the anonymous informant known as "Deepthroat." Another common link between ATPM and SG is showing how different editors can be. 

Though ATPM was a good movie, I think it ran on a little too long. Shattered Glass was better in my opinion. The movie really picks up after Stephen writes his final TNR story, Hack Heaven. I'm hoping another great journalism movie comes out soon. I'd like to see films based on Jayson Blair or Janet Cooke. I think SG and ATPM should be screened in every journalism class.

For those interested, here are two interviews with Stephen Glass.

0 Comments

Your comment will be posted after it is approved.


Leave a Reply.

    Picture
    Award-Winning Journalist A.J. Dugger III

    Promote Your Page Too

    Author

    A.J. Dugger is an Award-Winning Journalist.
    He is the author of the new horror anthology book SoUtHeRn TeRrOr, and The Dealers: Then and Now, the sensational story of his mother and uncles' career as a funk band.

    The Dealers: Then and Now

    Promote Your Page Too

    Enter your email address:

    Delivered by FeedBurner

    Archives

    October 2018
    May 2017
    April 2017
    March 2017
    January 2017
    December 2016
    July 2016
    May 2014
    April 2014
    March 2014
    February 2014
    January 2014
    December 2013
    November 2013
    August 2013
    July 2013
    February 2013
    May 2012
    March 2012
    January 2012
    December 2011
    November 2011
    October 2011
    August 2011
    July 2011
    June 2011
    May 2011

    Categories

    All
    2002
    2011
    2012
    Angelo Dundee
    Baritone
    Barrett
    Bass
    Bert Sugar
    Bite
    Blog
    Boxing
    Bruce Williamson
    Butch Lewis
    Curl
    David
    David Tua
    David Tua Retire
    Death
    Ear
    Evander Holyfield
    Fabricate
    Facebook
    Falsetto
    Frank Dileo
    Fraud
    Freelance
    George Foreman
    Ghostwrite
    Hair
    Haye
    Jack Dempsey
    Jackson
    Jheri
    Joe
    Joe Frazier
    Joe Herndon
    Joe Louis
    Journalism
    Larry Holmes
    Lennox Lewis
    Michael
    Michael Jackson
    Michael Spinks
    Mike Tyson
    Mills Lane
    Monte
    Monte Barrett
    Muhammad Ali
    Otis Williams
    Privacy
    Rematch
    Rocky Marciano
    Ron Lyle
    Ron Tyson
    Sonny Liston
    Stephen Glass
    Still Here
    Tenor
    Terry Weeks
    Theismann
    The Tempations
    Thriller
    Timeline
    Tnr
    Tua
    Undisputed
    Video Blog
    Vitali
    Wave
    Whitney Houston
    Wig
    Wladimir

    RSS Feed

Powered by Create your own unique website with customizable templates.