The Online Portfolio Of A.J. Dugger III
  • Home
  • Cover Stories & TV Appearances
  • Gallery Of Work
  • Books
  • Celebrity Interviews
  • Awards
  • Music
  • Blog

What If? David Tua Versus Primo Carnera

12/20/2019

0 Comments

 
Picture
Imagine the year is 1933 and you're a top-ranked heavyweight contender  stepping into the ring with the heavyweight champion. As the announcer pumps up the crowd during the introductions, the heavyweight champion glares at you from across the ring. He is a huge man, standing at a tall 6'6 and ½ inches and a massive 250 pounds. His name is Primo Carnera, (88-14, 71 Knockouts) and he just recently killed a man named Ernie Schaaf in a previous fight. You're about to face one of the strongest men alive on the planet, even capable of murder in the ring.

Let's fast forward to the year 2000. You're a boxer and the only man standing between you and a potential crack at the heavyweight championship is a strong, stocky powerhouse of a heavyweight named David Tua. (52-5-2, 43 Knockouts)

Tua may be on the small side standing at 5'10 and wearing a "Kid N' Play" haircut, but it doesn't matter. You've seen what his devastating left hook can do. He basically hits you with the entire island of Samoa. Tua has his Polynesian dancers drumming and dancing as he makes his way to the ring. As he climbs through the ropes, he shoots you the meanest look you've ever seen in your life. He has knocked out his last ten opponents in a devastating fashion and looks to add you to his list. You visibly shudder at the thought.

David Tua is arguably the greatest heavyweight never to win the title. But he was blessed with pure dynamite in his fists and had one of the best chins of all time. His left hook was pure blunt force trauma.

​Primo Carnera was also a warrior gifted with almost supernatural physical strength. He is one of the biggest heavyweight champions to ever fight in the ring. What would happen if these two mammoths clashed in the center of the ring? Who controls the action? Who goes down? Who has the better legacy? Let's discuss.
​
Picture
Standing at 6'6 and 250 pounds, the massive Primo Carnera would hold a significant size advantage over "The Throwin' Samoan."

The Ambling Alp


​Known as the Ambling Alp (What kind of name is that?!?!) Primo was the biggest heavyweight champion in history until the arrival of the 7-foot tall Nikolai Valuev. Carnera was incredibly strong, even working as a strongman and professional wrestler at one point.

Primo naturally had an intimating presence because of his size, but his scary reputation increased when he fatally knocked out Ernie Schaaf in February 1933. In the 13th round, a jab from the giant sent Schaaf sprawling to the canvas, and he never entirely woke up. He briefly awoke paralyzed in the hospital, but lapsed back into a coma and passed away 4 days later. Here is a clip of the knockout.  


Primo knocked out Jack Sharkey to win the heavyweight championship in 1933. In the 6th round, a vicious uppercut literally knocked Sharkey off his feet and took his title. What's ironic is that Sharkey had easily boxed his way to a decision over Primo in their previous encounter, but he was obviously intimated by Primo's “murderous” reputation in their title fight. The man was terrified.

Primo was not heavyweight champion for long. He was absolutely destroyed by Max Baer a year later, hitting the canvas 11 times. The referee mercifully stopped the massacre in the 11th round.

The following year, Primo was again humiliated...this time by a young up and coming Joe Louis. The Brown Bomber unloaded his dynamite and put Carnera on the floor three times. By the 6th round, it was over. This fight was the first major milestone in Louis' career. When he showed that he could knock out the massive Primo Carnera, people knew he had a future. Here is what Louis had to say about fighting Primo, brilliantly walking us through the fight.



Picture
Louis said here that “Carnera was nothing.” It's interesting that Louis was able to literally pick up the giant and not vice versa. This was an easy fight for Louis, and he makes it sound as if Primo wasn't as talented as people thought, which I'll get to in a second.

There are many rumors that Primo was controlled by the mob. I don't know the details of this, but if true, Louis' statements ring even more true. Primo was huge, but couldn't fight. His size and mob connections are what led to his success. But that's all a matter of opinion.


Picture

The Tuaman


That 19-second demolition you just witnessed is the entire David Tua-John Ruiz fight. Many of Tua's early fights went like this, and he was referred to by many as "The Samoan Mike Tyson." Like his hero Mike Tyson, David Tua often ended fights early in an explosive fashion.

After turning pro in 1992, David gained a reputation for being one of boxing's most feared sluggers. His trainers were Lou Duva, Ronnie Shields and Kevin Barry. Duva was friends with Rocky Marciano and said during one of Tua's  post-fight interviews that he gave his pupil a “Rocky Marciano style.” That may have been Duva's intent, but in my opinion David combined Tyson's aggressive approach with Joe Frazier's explosive left hook and stamina. Throw in a granite chin, and the result is David Tua.

David had a reputation for destroying guys within the first round, but he was also dangerous because he could go the distance no problem. There were many fights where David was behind on the scorecards but his bomb of a left hook bailed him out at the last second. Well, I guess you could compare him to Marciano in that regard. Marciano and Tua both had fights where their one-punch power saved the day at the last second.

Tua also had a chin of absolute granite. He was rarely hurt or staggered. Those huge tree trunk legs kept him sturdy.

Tua's first loss came to Ike Ibeabuchi in one of the best fights of all time. The battle was close. I had it 6-4-2 for Ike Ibeabuchi. Tua had issues adjusting to Ike's jab during the first four rounds, and Ike fought like hell to survive the last round, outpointing Tua. If not for his late start, Tua would have won.

Despite losing, this was Tua's best performance. He threw devastating combinations of hooks and uppercuts, he threw dozens of punches to the head and body almost consistently. Both guys wanted the win badly, and wound up having the highest number of punches thrown in a heavyweight fight.

​
Picture
After his undefeated streak was broken by Ibeabuchi, Tua seemingly lost his spirit. His weight began to balloon the next year in a fight with Hasim Rahman. Tua began to get bigger and bigger with each fight, and now fought a bit more lazy, often looking to end things with his thunderous left hook. The combinations, the uppercuts, and the thudding body blows were suddenly gone. It was now all about the left hook. This lack of strategy and motivation gradually ruined David's career.

Picture
David Tua narrowly missing a massive left hook on Lennox Lewis in 2000.

A Clash Of Styles


​Primo fought as an upright, outside boxer. He used his long 85-inch reach and jab to fight from the distance.

Tua, on the other hand, was the exact opposite. He charged right at you and launched his thudding hooks and uppercuts in close range.

If we go by what Louis said, Primo had a “pretty decent jab” and pushed with his right. What we know is that when sluggers slipped under his guard and landed on Primo's chin, he went down in a heap.

Max Baer and Joe Louis are the hardest punchers Primo fought, and they both shattered him easily once they landed their first significant punch. Louis wisely concentrated on a body attack during the early rounds to "soften" Primo up. Once Primo was visibly getting fatigued and began to drop his guard to protect his ribs, that's when Louis got aggressive and went for the kill. 

But Max Baer? He was a wild swinging madman. No finesse, no grace, no setup, just wild crazy random swings. If he could connect on Baer, I'm almost sure anyone could.

The difference between their victories against Primo is that Louis started setting Primo up as early as the first round, so it took less knockdowns to finish him later. Primo was broken down and ready to go by round 6. Baer hurt Primo earlier, but because he didn't "weaken" him the way Louis did, it took him a lot longer for Baer to finish the giant. (11 rounds).



Picture
Joe Louis struck Carnera so hard that blood squirted from his mouth and he went crashing to the floor.
Fighting big men wasn't necessarily a problem for Tua, but his kryptonite was a good jab, regardless of his opponent's size. Tua never learned how to sufficiently block or slip them. Hasim Rahman was far from a spectacular heavyweight, but because he had a decent jab, Tua had trouble adjusting to him in two fights.

Tua's defense was so bad that he made Hasim Rahman almost look as good as Joe Louis. Similarly, Chris Bryd had a field day humiliating Tua for 12 rounds. Bryd's awkward, pawing jab and slick mobility kept Tua befuddled and allowed Bryd to stay out of danger. Tua never learned how to sufficiently cut the ring either. If he had, then he would have mowed down Rahman and Bryd and pulverized them. But he had no idea how to close the gap if his opponent kept their jab in his face.

Tua might attack aggressively like a Frazier or Marciano, but he had no idea how to trap and corner guys the way they did.

During their heavyweight championship fight in November 2000, Lennox Lewis basically treated Tua like a sparring partner in one of his easiest title defenses.

But Primo Carnera was even bigger than Lennox Lewis, and we saw what happened when Tua fought Lewis. Does this mean Carnera would automatically beat Tua? Not necessarily.
​
Tua had knocked out guys as big as Lewis before, but none of them had Lewis' defense and skill. It was difficult getting around Lewis' reach, especially with him constantly shooting that jab.

Lewis also had his right hand prepared to surprise Tua with a straight right or uppercut. Once Tua felt the uppercut during the early rounds, he stopped attacking as much, knowing that this was the punch that awaited him if he got too close.  

Tua also had a rib injury that was aggravated early in the fight when Lewis struck him with a body shot. Whether it was the uppercut or the body punch to the rib (or both) Tua mentally submitted and followed Lewis around for the remainder of the fight in a trance, hoping to smash him with an explosive left hook that never connected. He had no plan B.


Picture
During the last 2 seconds of the fight, David desperately threw a left hook so wide that he threw himself into the ring post.
Lewis and his trainer Emanuel Steward had Tua all figured out long before the fight. In addition to keeping Tua at bay with his telephone pole jab, Lewis held his right hand near his jaw, protecting it from Tua's only threatening punch – the left hook.

Despite being bigger than Lewis, Primo didn't jab nearly as much, nor was his right hand as vicious. I also don't think he'd employ any set strategy to keep Tua off of him. Because Primo lacked proper defense, it's more than possible that Tua would sneak through and blast his jaw the way Louis and Baer did.

Then again, Tua could be a lazy fighter at times. There were many fights he had against big guys with minimal talent similar to Carnera –  David Izon, Oleg Maskaev, and Danell Nicholson immediately spring to mind. These guys were far from great fighters but they were having a fun time dismantling Tua until he suddenly landed that big left hook that put them to sleep.

​
Picture
Primo was so big that it was difficult for his opponents to get under his reach and attack him.

Legacy


Another reason why these two probably don't get the recognition they deserve is because their biggest victories in the ring are somewhat tainted. Primo's biggest win was over the much smaller and absolutely terrified Jack Sharkey.

As for David Tua, he knocked out four former heavyweight champions – Hasim Rahman, Michael Moorer, Oleg Maskaev, and John Ruiz. Ruiz was destroyed in 19 seconds and Moorer was blasted out in 30 seconds. But at the time Tua knocked out these men, none of them were the heavyweight champion.

Tua's biggest loss was to a peak Lennox Lewis, and his second biggest loss was to a young Chris Bryd.

Carnera's biggest losses were to Max Baer and Joe Louis. Primo's losses can be forgiven. Baer was one of the most dangerous punchers of all time. Joe Louis is arguably the greatest heavyweight champion of all time, so there isn't any shame in getting knocked out by those men.


Picture
Early on, Chris Byrd looked TERRIFIED of David Tua. But he soon realized he had nothing to worry about.

​Lennox Lewis was too good for Tua, but Tua could have given himself a chance if he'd thrown more punches. In Lewis' next fight, Hasim Rahman destroyed him with one punch and took his championships. Tua is a much harder puncher than Rahman. The difference between the two is that Rahman actually threw punches in his title fight with Lewis, and Tua didn't.

Tua lost his fight against Bryd for similar reasons. He spent the whole fight looking to smash the elusive Bryd with his fierce left hook. Bryd has a great chin and could roll well with a punch if he saw it coming. Tua landed plenty of body punches throughout the fight, but by the time Bryd started to slow down because of it, it was round 11 and the fight was nearly over.

Lennox Lewis said it best. “It takes a whole arsenal to beat Lennox Lewis, not just a left hook and a haircut.” A cocky statement, but true.

If I had to rank Carnera and Tua, I'd rank Carnera ahead. For starters, Primo actually won the heavyweight title, something Tua never did. Even sadder for Tua is that there were four heavyweight titles during his era and he never picked up a single one, while many lesser fighters did.

Secondly, Primo's biggest losses were understandable. Tua, on the other hand, fell in love with his power and had no strategy against Lewis and Bryd aside from smashing them with a huge left hook to the chin.



Picture
Sugar Ray Robinson hanging out with Primo Carnera and Joe Louis.


​Speed
​

​As far as mobility goes, Primo moved a bit better than Jess Willard, but he was no gazelle. Still, Carnera wasn't necessarily slow, but you could see most of his punches coming. You could say maybe he was average at best.

Tua's hand speed wasn't on the Tyson or Ali level, but when he's in range that left hook could certainly catch you by surprise. Ask Darroll Wilson about that. He and Tua were scuffling up close, and Wilson all of a sudden went down. Tua had snuck a left hook to his chin. 1st round knockout.

People used to compare Tua's left hook to Joe Frazier's, but Joe's was clearly better. Joe could launch that punch from any angle, and you often couldn't see it coming.

Joe would “double” his hook, throwing one left hook to the body and then another one to the head. BANG! BANG! It was this combination that sent Muhammad Ali staggering into the ropes during round 11 of the fight of the century in 1971.

Sometimes Frazier threw the left hook after a jab in one motion, and sometimes he threw the left hook after a right hand set-up.

Tua was more predictable, often leaning a bit to his left just before launching the punch. Generally, you could see his hook coming if he were more than a foot and half away. But up close? You'd never see it coming.... and wake up in the locker room.  
​
Picture
An older David Tua smashes an opponent with his left hook. Like George Foreman, Tua's power never faded.

The Fight

​
Here's what you've been waiting for. One guy (Tua) had awesome power, a concrete chin and no problem going the distance. The other (Carnera) was one of the biggest men to ever lace up the gloves and even killed a man in the ring. How does the fight go?

Well, it depends on Tua. The 1994-97 version of David Tua would attempt to smash Carnera immediately. It took Louis and Baer a few knockdowns to keep the giant down for good, but they succeeded. They also connected their blows rather easily.

If Louis said he had issues getting under Primo's guard during the first few rounds, so would Tua, who lacked Louis' defense and was even shorter. Louis broke Primo down with his jab and counters to the body, waiting for the perfect time to strike. That moment finally arrived in round 6.

The '90s version of Tua still had issues adjusting to jabs, but because Primo didn't throw that many and Tua kept attacking, he'd land that big left hook  midway through the fight after struggling a few rounds to close the gap. A surprised and outgunned Carnera would be repeatedly put on the canvas.

If it's the overweight David Tua that lost to Lennox Lewis, Carnera may stay in the game a bit longer, but it'd be the same result – Carnera tries to survive, but the referee stops the fight after the big man takes one left hook too many.

David Tua Wins By Sensational Knockout in Round 5.

​Agree? Disagree? Duke it out in the comments!
​

Picture
This would be the outcome of the fight. David Tua wins by 5th Round Knockout.
0 Comments
    Picture
    Award-Winning Journalist A.J. Dugger III

    Promote Your Page Too

    Author

    A.J. Dugger is an Award-Winning Television and Print & Media Journalist.

    He appears as a crime analyst on the TV-One crime series, For My Man, and is the author of four books: Black Journals,  the horror anthology SoUtHeRn TeRrOr, the mystery crime thriller Who KILLED Joel Larson? and The Dealers: Then and Now, the sensational story of his mother and uncles' career as a funk band.

    The Dealers: Then and Now

    Promote Your Page Too

    Enter your email address:

    Delivered by FeedBurner

    RSS Feed

    Categories

    All
    2002
    2006
    2011
    Abby
    Abigail Anderson
    Allie Colombo
    Allie Columbo
    Al Weil
    An American Werewolf In London
    Andre Bishop
    Anxiety
    Archie Moore
    Aron Tager
    Assault
    Autism
    Bad Intentions
    Barbara Cousins
    Baritone
    Barrett
    Barry Gordy
    Bass
    Batman
    Batman Forever
    Bel Biv DeVoe
    Berry Gordy
    Bipolar
    Bipolar Disorder
    Bite
    Black Hercules
    Blog
    Bloodsport
    Bluffington
    Bobby Brown
    Bolo Yeung
    BOXING
    Brockton
    Bruce Williamson
    Carmine Vingo
    Catwoman
    Charles Winkler
    Charley Goldman
    Charlie Goldman
    Chong Li
    Chris Ferry
    Chuck Lane
    Civil Rights
    Clifford Etienne
    Cody Darbe
    Crime
    Crook Brothers
    Curl
    Cus D'amato
    Damon Harris
    Dancin Machine
    David
    David Ruffin
    David Tua
    Death
    Dennis Edwards
    Deontay Wilder
    Depression
    Donald Ho
    Doug Funnie
    Drago
    Duane Jones
    Duke Desmond
    Ear
    Earnie Shavers
    Eddie Futch
    Eddie Kendricks
    Ellie
    Evander Holyfield
    Facebook
    Falsetto
    Fight To Survive
    Floyd Patterson
    Forest Whitaker
    Frank Dileo
    Frank Dux
    Frankie Carbo
    Freddy Krueger
    Freddy Versus Jason
    Freelance
    Friday The 13th
    Full Moon
    Gazelle Punch
    George C. Scott
    George Foreman
    Ghostwrite
    Hair
    Hasim Rahman
    Haye
    Hbo
    Heavyweight
    Heavyweight Champion
    Horror
    Ingemar Johansson
    Invincible
    Italian
    Jack Dempsey
    Jack Johnson
    Jackson
    Jackson 5
    Jason Takes Manhattan
    Jason Voorhees
    Jean-Claude Van Damme
    Jeffrey Crook
    Jheri
    Jimmy Jam And Terry Lewis
    Jimmy Young
    Joe
    Joe Frazier
    Joe Herndon
    Joel Larson
    Joel Miller
    Joe Louis
    Joel Schumacher
    Johnny Gill
    John Ruiz
    Jon Favreau
    Joshua Crook
    Journalism
    Judy Funnie
    Justin Timberlake
    Ken Kirzinger
    Ken Norton
    Kevin Rooney
    Kickboxer
    Knockout
    Kumite
    Larry Holmes
    Lauren Currie Lewis
    Left Hook
    Lennox Lewis
    Low Latent Inhibtion
    Ma
    Martial Arts
    Marvis Frazier
    Max Baer
    Memphis
    Mental Health
    Mental Illness
    Mentally Ill
    Michael
    Michael Jackson
    Michael Moorer
    Michael Spinks
    Mike Tyson
    Mills Lane
    Miss. Wingo
    Monte
    Monte Barrett
    Moonwalker
    Motown
    Moving Violation
    Muhammad Ali
    Murder
    Mystery
    Mystery Novel
    Nation Of Islam
    Naughty Dog
    New Edition
    New Jack Swing
    Nickelodeon
    Nightmare On Elm Street
    Novel
    On My Own
    Otis Williams
    Paco
    Patti Mayonnaise
    Peekaboo
    Penelope Ann Miller
    Phil Funnie
    Playstation 4
    Porkchop
    Primo Carnera
    Prince
    Principal Lamar Bone
    Privacy
    Ps4
    Ralph Tresvant
    Razor Ruddock
    Rematch
    Review
    Ricardo Morra
    Richard Nixon
    Richard Street
    Rick Grimes
    Rocky Marciano
    Roger Klotz
    Roland Lastarza
    Ron Tyson
    Salvage
    Schizophrenia
    Sensitivity
    Sister Ruth
    Skeeter Valentine
    Smash Adams
    Sonny Liston
    Southern Terror
    Stan Bush
    Stephanie Mcmahon
    Stephen Glass
    Still Here
    Stone Cold Steve Austin
    Sugar Ray Robinson
    Sumo
    Suspense Novel
    Suzy Q
    Suzy-q
    Teddy Atlas
    Teen Nick
    Tennessee
    Tenor
    Terry Weeks
    The Gentleman Of Boxing
    The Howling 4
    The Howling IV
    Theismann
    The Jawbreaker
    The Last Of Us Part 2
    The Making Of Thriller
    The Old Mongoose
    The Rock
    The Tempations
    The Temptations
    The Walking Dead
    Thriller
    Timeline
    Tommy Morrison
    Tony Galento
    Tony Lo Bianco
    Triple H
    Tua
    Tyson Fury
    Uncle Tom
    Undefeated
    Undisputed
    Victory
    Video Blog
    Vince Mcmahon
    Vitali
    Wave
    WBC
    Werewolf
    What If?
    Whodunit
    Who Killed Joel Larson?
    Wig
    Wladimir
    Wladimir Klitschko
    Wwf

    Archives

    January 2022
    December 2021
    March 2021
    February 2021
    November 2020
    September 2020
    March 2020
    February 2020
    January 2020
    December 2019
    November 2019
    October 2019
    September 2019
    August 2019
    July 2019
    May 2017
    April 2017
    March 2017
    January 2017
    December 2016
    August 2016
    July 2016
    May 2014
    April 2014
    March 2014
    February 2014
    January 2014
    December 2013
    November 2013
    August 2013
    July 2013
    February 2013
    May 2012
    March 2012
    January 2012
    December 2011
    November 2011
    October 2011
    August 2011
    July 2011
    June 2011
    May 2011

Powered by Create your own unique website with customizable templates.